Autobiography in Five Short Chapters

Autobiography in Five Short Chapters

What Portia Nelson's Autobiography in Five Short Chapters teaches about change, and what each chapter looks like in therapy.

By William Schroeder, LPC and clinically reviewed by Teri Schroeder, LCSW

Portia Nelson’s poem “Autobiography in Five Short Chapters” is something that we tend to use with clients going through a variety of tricky issues. It takes less than a minute to read, and it describes how change actually happens better than most therapy language does.

We don’t reprint the poem here. You can find it in Nelson’s book There’s a Hole in My Sidewalk, and it’s worth reading in full before you go further. Below is our summary of each chapter and what that stage tends to look like in therapy.

The Story in Brief

The poem follows one person walking down the same street again and again. There’s a deep hole in the sidewalk. Each chapter, the walker relates to that hole a little differently.

That’s the whole plot. It works because almost everyone has a hole like that, a pattern they keep landing in even when they swear this time will be different.

Chapter One: Falling In Without Seeing It

In the first chapter, the walker falls into the hole, feels lost and helpless, and is sure none of it is their fault. Getting out takes a very long time.

This is often where people are when they first reach out to us. Something keeps going wrong, in a relationship or at work, and it feels like it simply happens to them. The early work isn’t about blame. It’s about slowing down long enough to describe what happened, in detail, without judging it.

Chapter Two: Pretending Not to See It

The walker comes down the same street and sees the hole this time, but pretends not to. They fall in again, can’t believe they’re back, and still insist it isn’t their fault. Getting out is still slow.

In therapy, this is the stage of noticing patterns. Denial is a normal part of change, not a character flaw. A therapist might gently point out, “This sounds a lot like what happened last spring.” Writing things down helps, because a journal is harder to argue with than memory. Our post on how to journal for therapy walks through how to start.

Chapter Three: Falling In With Your Eyes Open

Now the walker sees the hole and falls in anyway, out of habit. The difference is that they know exactly where they are, they own their part in it, and they climb out right away.

This is taking responsibility, and it can feel worse before it feels better. You can see the mistake while you’re making it, which is frustrating. That frustration is progress.

Responsibility here isn’t self-punishment. It sounds more like, “I have a part in this, so I have some power over it.” Notice, too, that recovery time shrinks long before the falls stop.

Chapter Four: Walking Around the Hole

Same street, same hole. This time the walker sees it and steps around it.

This is building new habits. The trigger hasn’t gone anywhere. It might be the same coworker, the same holiday dinner or the same late-night urge. What changes is the response.

In session, we practice that new response until it becomes automatic, often by rehearsing a hard conversation or planning ahead for a predictable trigger. It takes repetition. One good week isn’t a solved problem, and one fall isn’t a failure.

Chapter Five: Choosing a Different Street

The final chapter is a single line: “I walk down another street.” (Portia Nelson)

Here, change stops being about avoiding the hole and becomes about choosing a different street altogether. Sometimes that means a big decision, like setting a firm boundary with family or leaving a job that keeps pulling you back in.

Sometimes it’s quieter, like a new way of spending your evenings or a different story about who you are. The hole is still out there. You just don’t build your days around it anymore.

How Does It Apply to Your Life?

Most of us are in different chapters with different holes at the same time. You might be in Chapter Four with work stress and Chapter One with your marriage. That’s normal.

A few questions to sit with:

  • What hole do you keep falling into?
  • Which chapter are you in with it right now?
  • What would walking around it look like this week?

If this way of thinking about change speaks to you, you can also read Why Self-Acceptance Is Important.

Help Finding a Different Street

Going through some tricky issues? We can be of assistance! Our therapists in Austin and across Texas by telehealth help people with exactly these kinds of patterns through adult counseling.

When you’re ready, make a counseling appointment and a real person on our team will match you with a clinician who fits.

Looking for Some More Guidance?

Sign up for our newsletter to get one or two emails a month with tips on parenting, relationships, anxiety, ADHD and everything in between.